Senior advocate and Rajya Sabha MP Kapil Sibal has ignited a firestorm just 48 hours before the May 4 results, questioning the "unprecedented" and "emergency-like" security grid draped over West Bengal. Representing the Trinamool Congress (TMC) in a high-stakes Supreme Court battle, Sibal lashed out at the Election Commission’s (ECI) decision to flood counting centers with central forces and central government personnel. "What is the need for such a huge deployment? Is there a war going on?" Sibal asked, alleging that the ECI is acting as a "part and parcel" of the BJP to intimidate the state machinery.
The TMC’s argument centers on a "textbook example of unjust executive action," claiming the ECI's April 13 circular deliberately sidelines state employees to give the Centre "direct control" over the counting process. Sibal argued that with nearly 2.4 lakh security personnel—roughly one for every 100 citizens—the atmosphere has been transformed into an "unconstitutional Emergency." The party fears that using Central PSU employees as counting supervisors creates an "apparent risk of bias," effectively allowing the BJP to fight the election through the CAPF and the ECI rather than on political merit.
However, the Supreme Court has dismissed these concerns as a "fallacy" born out of desperation. Disposing of the TMC's plea on May 2, the court observed that government officers belong to the ECI during poll time and owe no allegiance to any party. Supporters of the deployment point to West Bengal’s grim history of post-poll violence in 2021 as the primary "data" justifying the iron-clad security. BJP spokespersons have slammed Sibal’s rhetoric, asserting that the heavy deployment is the only way to ensure a "free and fair" count in a state where political friction often turns fatal.
